Category Archives: NBA

NBA Loser Wish List

As 94% or so of the NBA teams are at home, or the beach, and not playing in the NBA Finals.  So the teams that we close, but yet so far away – everyone sing it –  must start to think about what the playoff loser needs to make the leap to the Finals.

Cleveland Cavs

  • Scottie Pippen – or someone to take that role.
  • A mid range jumper and a post game for LeBron James.
  • Someone over 6’5″ who can play perimeter defense.
  • Charles Oakley – see Scottie Pippen.

Denver Nuggets

  • JR Smith to pull his head from his butt.
  • Chauney Billups to stop jacking ill-advised three and get the ball to Carmelo.
  • To stop making stupid plays and fouls.

Boston Celtics

  • Two new knees for KG.
  • Brain Scalabrine in street clothes.
  • For everyone named KG, Paul Pierce and Jesus Shuttlesworth to become younger.
  • Doc Rivers to learn how to coach.

Houston Rockets

  • A really talent doctor.
  • Trade Tracy McGrady.
  • Ron Artest to stop jacking ill-advised three and get the ball to Yao.
  • Good medical insurance.

Atlanta Hawks

  • Decide what kind of team they want to be.
  • A trade for a real post player – get rid of Marvin Williams.
  • Mike Bibby to take less money.
  • Another All-Star level player.

Dallas Mavericks

  • Depth in the post with better rebounding – there is another German in Chris Kaman who is pretty good and may need a new home.
  • Jason Kidd to continue shooting well.
  • Josh Howard to play like Jason Terry.

Miami Heat

  • Say good-bye to Jermaine O’Neal.
  • Find experienced player through in free agency or the draft.
  • Another Dwayne Wade – just 6’11”.

Portland Trailblazers

  • A better point guard or Jerryd Bayless to get sometime.
  • Travis Outlaw to continue evolving.
  • Rudy, Rudy, Rudy!
  • To go back a couple years a pick Kevin Durant instead of Greg Oden.

Philadelphia 76ers

  • Sign Andre Iquodala!  SERIOUSLY!
  • Elton to play some basketball!
  • A consistent shooting guard.

San Antonio Spurs

  • Tim Duncan to reverse his aging.
  • Manu.  More Manu!
  • Another scoring option as unless Duncan can take care of his issue.
  • Gregg Papovich to shave that damned beard!

Chicago Bulls

  • Make a decision on Kirk Hinrich and Ben Gordan.  Please!
  • A shooter guard over 6’4″.

New Orleans Hornets

  • Bring back Jeremy Pargo!
  • Some other than Chris Paul to score 20 points a game.
  • Low post toughness.

Detroit Pistons

  • Get younger, quick.
  • Let Allen Iverson and Rasheed Wallace go.  It’s time boys.
  • Athletic, slashing shooter guard who can get to the rim.

Utah Jazz

  • Sign Carlos Boozer for less money.
  • See last point for the Pistons!
  • A legit 6’11” low post player who only blocks and grab rebounds – Dwight Howard?

NBA Finals Preview: Lakers Vs. Magic

More so than the regular season, the playoffs are all about match-ups and how you take advantage of those situations.  The Orlando Magic have taken this idea to a whole new level and ridden it all the way to the NBA Finals.

As the Magic finished off the Cleveland Cavaliers in the Eastern Conference Finals, it only seems natural to look at the Finals and the match-ups that will make or break a teams chance at winning a title.

Point Guard: Laker’s Derek Fischer Vs. Magic’s Rafer AlstonRafer Alston

I will ignore the fact the Hedo Turkoglu handles the ball about 70% of the time, especially after opponents made baskets.

The winner of this match-up will be determined by who shots better and turns the ball over less.

Fischer is most effective as a spot-up shooter, but his shooting numbers late in the season and in the playoffs have been pretty poor.  He has averaged 26.3 minutes a game has shot 12-for-51 from distance (23.5%) and 35-for-118 from the field for 35.6% for a total of 7.1 points a game.

Alston has been scoring more, 12.7 ppg in the playoffs, but is also more prone to turnovers, 1.78 a game.  But his role is very similar to Fischer: “hit open shots”.

Alston is winning the ultimate PG stat assist per game: 4.4 to Fischer’s 2.4.

Advantage: Alston – In the playoffs, Fischer has scored in the double figures, five, in as many games as Alston has not. (Excluding game 5 of the Celtics series when he was suspend.)Kobe Bryant

Shooting Guard: Laker’s Kobe Bryant Vs. Magic’s Courtney Lee

Look for a continuation of a Lee – Mickael Pietrus combo, but Bryant still tops their scoring totals 26.8 to 19.2.  Pietrus has taken on the Brice Bowen role for the Magic as the defensive specialist and guy in the corner hitting threes.  Lee has a nice mid-range jumper and is more of a slasher then Pietrus.  And Kobe is Kobe.

Both Lee (6’5″  and 200 lbs) and Pietrus (6’6″ and 215 lbs) physically match-up well with Bryant (6’6″ and 205), but you are talking about Kobe.

Advantage: Kobe – It’s Kobe.

Small Forward: Laker’s Trevor Arzia Vs. Hedo Turkoglu

hedo-turkogluArzia is long enough and athletic enough to match-up and stay with Turkoglu.  Turkoglu has issues with players that are quicker than he is, not bigger.  But Ariza has size (6’8′) and speed to stay with Turkaglu from the perimeter to the post.

Turkoglu has been inconsistent with his shooting in the playoffs, but he always is willing and able in the clutch.  His scoring is down to 15.2 ppg from 16.8, but his assists are slightly higher and in Orlando’s closet games, the Magic look to Turkaglu to make their offense go.

Arzia is definitely not the first, second, or third option on offense for the Laker’s, but he is averaging 11.4 ppg while shooting 50% from behind the arc.

Even though this match-up will be close, I think Turkoglu will find ways to get his numbers and be the go-to guy in the forth quarter.

Advantage: Turkoglu – To many ways to score.

Power Forward: Laker’s Pau Gaso and Lamar Odom Vs. Magic’s Rashard LewisLamar Odom

Much like the shooting guard situation with the Magic, Lamar Odom very well could start at the four spot and then Gasol would move to the five spot.

Lewis is Orlando’s forgotten man, but the Magic would be forgotten without him.  He has caught fire in the playoffs – 19.4 ppg, 40% shooting from deep and 44% total shooting) and has the best offensive low-post game on the team.

The issue with Lewis is that he is a match-up problem for 99% percent of the teams in the league, the Laker’s are in the 1% and Laker’s coach Phil Jackson has no problem flipping starting line-ups if he feels it betters his team, and while I am not convinced Gasol can or will guard Dwight Howard, he cannot guard Lewis.  But Odom can.

Odom is Lewis, just a couple years older and not as consistent of a shooter.  Odom does have a low post game that is hard to stop and he is a lefty, which is always tricky.  Odom is a better rebounder than Lewis (9.5 rpg vs. Lewis’ 6.1 rpg) and Odom, when on and busting his butt, is the deference on this team.

This match-up comes down to Odom deciding how hard he wants to play.  While Lewis has scored 14 or more points in every playoff game, Odom has only done it six times.  But the Laker’s are 5-1 in those six games.  So if Odom plays like this is his last chance at a title, the match-up goes to the Laker’s, but I am not sure he will.

Advantage: Odom – when he plays well, the Lakers win.

Center: Laker’s Pau Gasol Vs. Magic’s Dwight HowardDwight Howard

Can anyone say polar opposites?  Gasol is finesse and Howard is strength.  Gasol is crafty while Howard is a better athlete.  Gasol can hit from 17 feet, Howard will hit you with an elbow – and then get suspended for it.  Gasol is soft on defense, and Howard is the Defensive Player of the Year.

Howard average 5.33 fouls a game against the Cav’s (we’ll call that the LeBron Effect), and fouled out in half of the last six games.  Howard will be able to keep his counterpart in check mostly by holding his ground, but he can get into foul trouble when flying to the rescue when helping on weak defense.

While Gasol is never considered the defensive power that Howard is, it is interesting that in the playoffs, Gasol is averaging 2 blocks a game and Howard 2.2, but Howard out-rebounds Gasol 15.4 to 11.3.

Gasol has been tougher in the Laker’s last two games, but he will get out worked and physically out matched against Howard.

Advantage: Magic – Gasol can’t stop Howard, but Gasol will be productive and make Howard guard him.


Both teams have a few players that come in to change the game.  For Orlando it is Pietrus, Marcin Gortat, and Anthony Johnson with Pietrus as the only bench player contributing offensively and getting meaningful minutes (25.3 a game).  The Magic have shorten their bench up in the playoffs unless their is foul trouble, then we may see Tony Battie.

Gortat has been a nice surprise and has stepped-up when Howard gets in foul trouble.  In the game Howard was suspended, Gortait played 40 minutes, grabbed 15 boards and had 11 points.  Jameer Nelson could be a nice spark – he has been a Laker killer this season – or he could also mess up the chemistry the team has found in the playoffs.

The Lakers are deeper than the Magic and typically run with Luke Walton, Lamar Odom, Shannon Brown, Jordan Farmer and Sasha Vujacic.  They also have Josh Powell and DJ Mbenga to bang with Howard and give up their twelve fouls.

Odom should start, so Bynum will come of the bench and add height, skill, and muscle and is the best match-up for the Lakers to play Howard straight up.

Brown has jumped over Farmer as the first guard off the bench and provides a spark of the bench.  Brown is a much better than he was in college, but still has the hops to throw it down.  He is also shooting 44% from the floor and 48% from behind the arc.

Jackson has always relied on his bench, we saw it with in Chicago and he continues to rely on them in crucial moments in the game.

Advantage: Laker’s – too much talent.

Coaching – Laker’s Phil Jackson Vs. Magic’s Stan Van GundyPhil Jackson

Not sure how you can argue against Jackson, so I will not – there is not much argument.  Van Gundy is underrated, but not that underrated.  Jackson has nine rings.

Advantage: Laker’s – he needs one more ring to cover all his fingers.

Grand Total: – Laker’s – 4 and Magic – 3

This series will be a battle, and it always comes down to match-ups.  The game changing match-up is Odom Vs. Lewis.  Both are going to be tough guards for the other, but Odom has been the unreliable.

The Laker’s should win, but the Magic have been proving all the critics wrong.  So I am picking the Magic in six games.

NBA vs. College Basketball

This argument comes down to one thing:  In the NBA, players play for the name on the back of the jersey.  In college the players play for the name on the front.

Too simple?  Yes.

True?  I think so.

Quality arguments can be made to point out the positives and negatives on whether the NBA or college basketball is superior. Even after this article, you will still have a preference, and that is good.  Yet I believe that a vast majority of sports lovers assume that the NBA is “better” because the talent is stronger and the players are more mature – last point is debatable.

One disclaimer – everything is the NBA is about money, and a good portion of college ball is as well, but the NCAA can’t admit that.  With that said, I will not need to breakdown the “why do they play”, because we all know.

Let’s breakdown by certain factor’s.  And I will decide the winner of those categories, and the side with the most “points”, wins.

JerseysLeBron James

NBA – Every team in the NBA has at least three different jerseys (if you are the LeBrons, you have 17).  The jerseys range from classics with the Lakers and Celtics, to the WNBAish with the Timberwolves and the Kings.  And you will always know the players because the names are always on the back.

When the average fan purchases a jersey they are usually supporting the individual, not the team.

84254635MW087_NCAA_Second_RCollegeThe college jerseys are not as visual creative and rarely do you have “throw back night”, but I have not seen a jersey that makes me wonder if they accidentally put on the girls team’s jersey.  Certain schools will never put the names on the back, and some have removed the players name to drive the point home that we are one team – not just players.

When the average fan (or alumni) purchases a jersey they are usually supporting the school, not the individual.

Also, you can just by a jersey with any number and unless the player is incredible and the number is retired, you might be able to use it again and again.

Winner = Tie, both are sweet.


NBA The NBA is full of teams with new stadiums that are shiny, glitzy, and in HD.  Now, name two famous/historic stadium.  Madison Square Garden, huh, wait there has to be at least one more…nope.  That’s it.

CollegeUnlike the pro’s, the undergrads study in historic buildings.  Cameroon Indoor Stadium, the Hoosier Dome, Williams Arena (Minnesota), etc.  And there are many more.

So this comes down to personal preference.  Do you like the old or new?

Winner = College.  I think everyone needs a reminder of those who have been there before.


NBA They have many costume changes and get to perform a ton, and might even get to be on a  calender or two.  The downside is that there are probably more implants in the NBA than in college.

CollegeThe cheerleaders are typically less “dancy”, and there is more traditional cheer leading.  Sometimes co-ed, so pyramids and flips are frequent.   But my wife thinks it is weird – and a little creepy –  that the fans are gawking at teenagers.  Good point.

Winner = NBA.  At least they get paid and they are legal.


NBA Six fouls, 48 minutes, 24 second shot clock, 8 seconds to get over half court.

The rules in the NBA lean towards the one-on-one game.  The introduction of the “zone” has made it better.

College Five fouls, 40 minutes, 35 second shot clock, 10 seconds to get over half court.

The college game leans towards team play and strategy.

If the college game would increase the foul limit to six and increase minutes, this would not be a contest.  But they have yet to do it.

Winner = NBA.  Sometimes 5 fouls just is not enough.


NBAI am not even going to factor the case of a certain ref named Tim into this equation, that would be unfair.  Some experts say that refs control the games in the NBA more than any other element, and can then pick a winner and it becomes obvious in the way they call the game.

The league has been calling touch fouls on anyone in the area of their stars for years, but now, anyone can get tick-tack fouls on their way to the basket and on the perimeter.  Prime example – hand checks.

College Every time a player steps on the court they have to be ready to adjust to whomever calls the game – the same is true in the NBA, but I think the refs are a little more consistent.  Plus, the way the game is called usually allows the players to play a little more, which is why we watch.

Winner = College.   Give the players a chance to play.

Jerry SloanCoaches

NBA The coaches on certain teams are more high school counselor than NBA coach.  Teams are made up of grown men who are trying to make a living and have ego’s as big – or bigger than most of their second homes.

If the association, unless you are a top-tier coach, you are more expendable than the worst players on their teams.  Coaches rarely get credit for wins, but always get the blame for loses.

Breaking into the ranks of head coach is more difficult in the NBA than any other sport, but once you are in the coaching carousal, even if you are fired – you stay on the ride.

College Coaches are the face of the program. And everyone is very aware of that.  Some would say that coaches in college have bigger ego’s and need to be the center of attention than their counterparts in the league.

A college coaches duties are pretty year round and always changing with the different roster that appears each season.  You have recruiting and players leaving early which means the ability to adjust on the fly is very important.

There is a better chance for coaches to get their “break” and land a good job.

Winner = NBA.  Longer season, but recruiting is not in the job description.  And you don’t have to deal with alumni.


NBA One could swear that the mute button is on until halfway through the fourth quarter.

CollegeThe stadiums are always full with students and alumni.  They sing their school songs and go nuts even at 11 am.

Winner = College.  This really wasn’t a contest – the NBA didn’t stand a chance.

Style of Play

NBAThe NBA has long been a league that allows for individuals to showcase their ability to beat defenders one-on-one.  The idea of team defense is all about weak side help, doubling the post and a little zone.  The NBA is quicker at times, but comes down to players making plays in crucial, end-of-game situations.

College– Each squad has to establish their own style and the ability of that team to dominate tempo.  Each possession means more because there less throughout the game.  There are more swings in the success of the team and the crowd can really affect how teams play.

Winner =NBA.  Systems are good, but players should decide games.  And in the NBA they do, if the refs let them.


NBA – Finally.  I always feel that way.  Getting through the regular season can be like getting teeth pulled, but the playoffs are magical (see Bulls vs. Celtics).  Many feel the playoffs are too long, the seeding needs to get reworked and that good teams are left out.  But that last point happens in every sport.

College – There are upsets and underdogs making runs deep into the tournament, players can take their lead their team over better teams and make names for themselves.  The only issue is that many times really good get left out on selection Sunday.

Winner = College.  From the brackets to watching the games online at work and every game matters.

Acquisition of Players

NBA – The NBA draft is fun to watch.   It is short and you usually have a good idea of who is going where.

Free agency is a toss-up.  It can help a team rebuild really fast (the Spurs are experts at this), but it also decreases the amount of players that stick with teams their whole careers.  Even All-Stars Tracy McGrady and Vince Carter have played for at least two different teams (T-Mac has played for three – Raptors, Magic and Rockets).

College – Recruiting is interesting to follow and you can keep busy all year round.  With coaching changes and kids changing their minds, it is a very fluid situation.

I understand the “sit-out-a-year” rule when you transfer from one D1 school to another, but think it should be changed if their is a coaching change or family hardship.

Winner = College.  Money is not involved – at least I hope not.  Oh wait.

Final Tally

I think have covers the majority of important issues that make each game unique onto itself.  Even after this extremely logical argument, there will be some that will disagree, and that is OK.  Because you are wrong, or least “less-right”.

Winner = College 6 to the NBA’s 4.

DTP 2008-09 NBA Awards

The regular season has come to a close.  It has been a great season in many respects.  We have seen rookies play major parts on good teams and on bad teams.  We have seen players develop from starters to stars, stars to MVPs.  Teams that should have been better and teams that made us glance at the standings sheet one last time.

Now the time has come when the big boys are no longer playing for fun, it is playoff time.  And to further inflate the ego’s of those making way too much money, we give them awards.

Like everyone that has any opinion on basketball, Matthew and I have our own and we made our choices.  We agreed on some, but not on all.  Either way, enjoy.

Rookie of The Year82989522CC019_Orlando_Magic

  • Matthew’s PickDerrick Rose – This has proved to be a very good, very deep class.  And Rose has stayed on top of it the entire season, ultimately leading his team into the playoffs.  Averaging 17 points, 4 boards, and 7 assists is a pretty nice line for a rookie…..or anybody.
  • Daniel’s PickDerrick Rose – The Bulls played like a bad high school team earlier this year, because they did not know how to use the talent the had.  The coach final made some changes and the Bulls are here.  Rose is the cornerstone for this franchise.

Most Improved Player

  • Matthew’s Pick:  Brandon Roy – Scoring three more points a game and has turned into the undeniable leader of a good, young squad.
  • Daniel’s PickDanny Granger – 7.5, 13.9, 19.6, and 25.8.  This is the season scoring average since his rookie year in 2005.  He has also become a better free-throw shooter since his first season, improving from 78% to 88% this season.  Like Rose, Granger is the cornerstone for his team.   PS – All Star.

Most Disappointing Team

  • Matthew’s Pick:  Phoenix Suns – Even without Amare, they’re like an all-star team from 5-10 years ago.
  • Daniel’s Pick:  Detroit Pistons – This team is rebuilding.  But you still have Rip, Rasheed and Prince.  The trade for Allen Iverson was not good for this season, but it will be good for the future.  Even so, this team was sad. 

Most Surprsing Team

  • Matthew’s Pick:  Denver Nuggets – Who would’ve guessed they would be the No. 2 seed in the West?  Not me! 
  • Daniel’s Pick: Charlotte Bobcats – They made a huge push late in the season and were close to making the playoffs. They beat the Lakers twice and have a solid group of players.  Just don’t pick-up AI. 

Sixth Man of the Year

  • Matthew’s Pick:  Lamar Odom – Sure he started a few games.  But his ability to be a solid option in the starting five when called upon,  stregthens his case.  
  • Daniel’s PickJason Terry – He is pretty much a stater.  Terry plays 33 mins a game, scores 20 points per game and is the man for Dallas in the clutch.


Coach of the Year:NBA/

  • Matthew’s Pick:  Stan Van Gundy –  Anytime you linger around 60-wins, you should be instantly part of the discussion, and he made things work pretty well without Jameer Nelson.
  • Daniel’s PickMike Brown–  66 wins and 16 loses.  His team scores 100 points per game and only give 91 (which is best in the league).  Yes, he has LeBron.  But this team is about defense.  And they allow their opponents to only shoot 33% from distance and 43 from the field (best in the league).  And he has LeBron.


  • Matthew’s Pick: LeBron James– He leads his squad in points (28), rebounds (8), assists (7), blocks (1.5) and steals (1.7).  That is ridiculous.
  • Daniel’s PickLeBron James – See above with one addition.  His squad =  best in the league.

Good Year to be an NBA Fan

You have to love how the sports seasons align.  It really is brilliant.  Just when the NFL season ends, college basketball gets good.  Just when the Final Four ends, baseball starts and the NBA Playoffs are just around the riverbend.

For those who have not been paying attention, this has been a good year to be ankobe_lebron NBA fan.  A few reasons:

1.  Kobe vs. Lebron

David Stern must be loving life right now with these two guys playing in his league.  The two best players in the world happen to be playing on the two best teams in the league.  They both have charasmatic personalities and, by the time they’re both done, they will have established themselves as 2 of the top-10 players of all-time.  Yes, I just said that.

2.  Lakers vs. Celtics

Everybody likes history.  Having these two teams once again part of the league’s elite has been fun to watch.  The only thing better than seeing these two teams clash again in the Finals would be seeing Kobe vs. Lebron in the Finals.

3.  A Lot of Fun-to-Watch Talentroy

Dwight Howard is a physical freak.  Chris Paul brings the playground to the NBA and does it well.  Dwayne Wade is an absolute stud (in the class of Kobe and Lebron, but his team keeps him out of the #1 discussion above).  Chauncey Billups is reminding people that he is really good at basketball regardless of the team he’s onBrandon Roy is the new guy in town, and is making me more resentful of Kevin McHale with each game he plays (the T-Wolves drafted him and then traded him).

4.  The Spurs Aren’t Favorites 

I’ll be the first to say that I appreciate how the Spurs play.  The Big Fundamental is consistently underappreciated.  But I’ll also be the first to say that they are boring.  Effective?  Extremely.  Entertaining?  No.  They’ll make the playoffs, but now that Manu Ginobli is gone for the season, they won’t get far.  That leaves room for more fan-friendly teams like the Blazers and Jazz and…everybody else.

5.  The East is Back    

The Eastern Conference has basically been the JV version of the West since Michael Jordan retired (from the Bulls).  But now the East is home to 3 of the top 4 teams in the league with the Cavs, Celtics, and Magic leading the way.  Not to mention, the Atlanta Hawks play a pretty fun brand of team basketball, and Dwayne Wade always makes the Heat a dangerous squad.  

Lesson for today:  watch the NBA Playoffs this year.  You will not be disappointed.

Block or Charge: The Most Difficult Call in Basketball

They can it a “bang-bang” play.  It happens so fast.  But don’t worry.  No one is dead, but there are probably a body or two on the floor staring blankly at the refs as the refs stare at each other with the “did you get that” look of fear in their eyes.

The block or charge call is the most difficult in all of basketball, and maybe in all of sports.  Many variables have to line-up at the moment one player collides into another player, all which a ref must process to decide what gesture he makes.

Was the defender moving ?  Was his feet set?  Did the offensive player lead with his shoulder?  Did the defender come under the offensive player as he was landing?  Was the player outside the circle?  Do I count the basket?

Between the  first weekend of  the NCAA tourney and the NIT, there were plenty of games in prime-time, and refs have had to make the dreaded call.  Mostly recently was last night, Penn State playing at Florida in the NIT quarter-finals.  Side-Note:  the Gator crowd was rockin’ and was treated to a great game.

Late in the game PSU guard Talor Battle drove baseline, left his feet for a finger-roll, and Florida guard Nick Calathes set his feet and prepared for the hit while Battle was in the air.  What is the call?  The ref called a charge, but counted the basket.


There are a handful of variations of the call, this however, is the most idiotic variation of the “most difficult call” – which will be refer to as “the call” from this point forward.

The PSU guard made a good move, started his shot legally, but was called illegal because another player moved underneath him prior to Battle landing safely, which he could not do because a player was in the way.  But it must not have been that illegal, because the ref counted the basket.

Even the commentators were miffed by “the call” – granted they have the luxury of a second look at the play in slow-motion – and they made their options known.  Many commentators have been very vocal in this conversation.  I vaguely remember a Jeff Van Gundy rant about this topic a few months ago when ESPN swapped announcers, putting the NBA crew with Van Gundy on the Duke vs. Davidson game.

SideNote:  I was not a Van Gundy fan when he was coaching, but I think he is just crazy enough to be entertaining as a broadcaster.

The NBA has made steps to take some variables out of “the call”.  By putting the half circle on the floor, a couple of feet out from the bottom of the net and calling it the “restricted area”, the call becomes much easier.  No matter if the defender is set, if his feet are touching that line, it is a block.  Plan and simple.

In the NBA, almost every player can jump outside of the lane and land in that “under the basket” area and the possibility of injury is greater.  Not so in college.

Another important aspect of “the call” that is over looked is the defenders right to that same space.  To say that the offensive player has more right to that spot on the court is absurd.  yet, that unconscious prejudice affects the way the call is made.

If a ref is “bias” in that they believe the offensive player is dictating the action, then the call is simple, read the reaction of the defender to the action of the offensive player.  Depending on what transpires, the call is quite obvious.  But if you believe that the defensive player is predicting a move prior to the offensive move happening, then it is the defender who dictates the action and then the reaction.

That is an extreme simplification of the call, but is exactly what I found when searching for some definition regarding “the call”.  Take a look at this post from

The post from is dated 2001 and directory speaks to the ability for a player to land and even change direction when outside the lower box.  By that definition, the call against Battle against Florida was incorrect.  Even if he landed around the basket, his move was initiated outside the lane.  While this maybe be the rule in college, it does not seem to have that level of detail.  I did search for the NCAA rules, but what unable to find the rulebook online.

No matter what the call maybe, they greater issue may be the fact that “the call” varies greatly from game to game and ref to ref.  Which leads the the single most important trait in a referee: consistency.

From call to call, players and coaches are part of a guessing game to determine how the refs will call the game.  Every call leaves a small portion of interpretation, i.e. carrying, traveling, and three seconds in the lane.  But that amount of interpretation seems to vary great when the refs will allow a certain amount of physical play in the first half, but then could call a hand check in the second half.  And we all have seen it.

There have been many articles and quotes that have debated this issue to now end.  Yet, the block/charge issue is becoming dangerous. As players get stronger and faster, there is a need to limit the variation and solidify a standard that will stop the players looking for the easy charge (We won’t even go into flopping – whole other issue).

With greater concistency and preparation, payers will no longer be rewarded for sneaking over to anticapte the landing point of a player in the air.  Or an offensive player who lowers the shoulder, expecting a block call.  The charge/block is the call that needs consistency, period.  With a few, specific changes, “the call” will not be so difficult.